Clicky

On TV Envy: The Oprah Winfrey Show to End in 2011

We’re giving away a limited edition Modern Warfare 2 Xbox 360 bundle!

We are kicking off our holiday giveaways with a bang! We’ve teamed with our friends at shoot it! to bring you this Modern Warfare 2 Xbox 360 limited edition console, a $400 value. The bundle includes a custom Xbox 360 console with exclusive design, a 250GB Xbox 360 hard drive, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2, a pair of black controllers, and more. It hits stores on November 10th, and we’ve pre-ordered one that we’re giving away to one of you. Be sure to check out the giveaway rules to see how to enter!

Latest Video: FilmCrunch 067: Hairspray, Chuck & Larry, Premonition reviewed

Veronica Santiago and Neil Estep review Hairspray, Chuck & Larry, and Premonition in this episode of FilmCrunch.
Play Video
Close Player   Episode Permalink Comment on this Video Subscribe to this show via iTunes, Miro, or RSS Download for: iPod High Definition
Thursday May 10, 2007 5:35 pm

Lost: The Man Behind the Curtain - David’s Top Five of Awesomeness

Share

Posted by David L. Williams Categories: Action, Sci-Fi/Horror, NBC, Lost, Editorial, Features, HDTV

LostAnother week, another very cool and dark episode of .  Perhaps the greatest accomplishment of this episode is that it redeemed, be it ever so slightly, the miserable mess that was Tricia Tanka is Dead (or something close to that; I’m so annoyed with that episode I don’t even want to go look it up) by showing us that Roger Workman is really Ben’s father.  It was a creepy episode, with thankfully lots of Locke and Ben, and, of course, lots of awesome things.  Shall I name 5?

It’s Still Super Dark - Last week was a very dark episode, not just dark for Lost, but dark for prime time network TV in general.  Now, true, I don’t watch the approximately eight million television shows that deal with an elite group of crime fighting professionals that set out to stop a surprising number of serial killers, so I can’t say for sure that Lost is the darkest show on TV, however, this week’s episode started with a woman dying in childbirth, featured a father who told his son (the young, Harry Potter-ish Ben) that this was Ben’s fault, and went on to include a father killing his son, a foreboding cabin in the woods, the death of several people at once in a “purge,” and, finally, a mass grave.

ABC’s owned by Disney.  Just to remind you.  The fact that Disney’s allowing this kind of darkness, that’s pretty awesome.

Ben’s “Psycho” - No, I’m not saying that Benjamin Linus is psychotic; I’m saying that in Jacob’s cabin he was doing quite a reenactment of Anthony Perkins talking to his “mother” in the movie Psycho.  But this was something different and equally as spooky.  He was utterly convincing, I mean, he really seemed to believe somebody was there.  Is Ben crazy?  Well, that’s possible.  Somebody who’s been on that island for so long, never knew his mother, killed his father ... would you really be surprised if a guy like that snapped?  Is Ben lying?  Well, that’s possible too.  Ben’s been lying since we met him, strung up in one of Rousseau’s traps.  He could have easily staged this elaborate ruse of Jacob’s cabin in order to scare Locke or anybody else who questions Ben back into submission.  From the moment Ben brought Locke into that cabin until the poltergeist-like barrage that sent both of them running out, that was a supremely creepy scene.  In a word: awesome.


The Return of the Smoke Monster - “What do you mean?,” you might ask.  “I never saw the smoke monster.”  I beg to differ with you there.  Ben’s mom showing up and speaking to him from across the barrier, that to me had all the earmarks of a visit from Smokey him/her/itself.  It reminded me so much of Jack seeing his father, Ekko talking to his brother, etc., and those all seem to have been Smokey-related.  I’m still not clear on what the purpose of the creature is (other than to make the people on the island have heart-breaking moments with people who are long gone), but I love watching it work.  You’ve gotta admit, the smoke monster is pretty awesome.

New Questions - A couple of weeks ago I used “Definite Answers” as one of the five awesome things about an episode, but now I have to admit that sometimes I love getting new, interesting questions.  Ever sat with your coworkers and talked about Lost and everybody keeps firing questions like, “What is Jacob really?” and “Why did they mention a volcano?”  Have you noticed that people tend to be smiling when they say, “I don’t know.”  The questions, the very cool questions, are what keep us coming back to Lost.  They’ve given us a bunch of answers this year (in spite of people complaining, they really have), and it’s only fitting that they bring up new questions too.  I mean, honestly, what’s up with Richard?  How is he roughly the same age (but now with a haircut) and Ben’s thirty years older?  How cool was it to see him talk to young Ben?  And how awesome is it that we have new questions?

Guy, Ben Shot Locke - I mean, how jaw-dropping was that moment, really?  Ben has been threatened by Locke for a long time, but I never thought he’d go that far.  Michael Emerson is a fantastic actor, and last night I realized that he’s playing Ben like a predatory animal.  Cunning when he’s in control, and hissing and dangerous when he’s cornered.  To have Locke, one of the most iconic characters of the series, get gut shot and dropped into a mass grave as a cliffhanger ... I mean, how much more awesome can you get?

Bonus 6th Awesome Thing - Help Me - Why does Jacob need help?  Why is he asking Locke for help?  Why couldn’t Ben hear it?  What the hell is up with that brief half-second shot of Jacob in the chair?  Help Me = Awesome.

Just one more episode and then the finale.  Can’t wait!


Advertisement

Comments:

Not sure I understand why you are SO down on the Hurley ep from earlier in the year. I can understand it not being your fave episode, but you seem to think it was just awful television.

What was wrong with it? It had a lot of laughs, great Sawyer-isms, some foreshadowing to the Ben episode, Kate and Saewyer returning to camp, and it was FUN.

I mean, it’s obvious that you dig the “darker” aspects of the show (being as it’s your no. 1 most awesome thing listed above), but just because something is lighter doesn’t mean it’s no good.

That ep was very funny, and a much needed break from a VERY dark season. C’mon dude, don’t be afraid to smile now and then!

I didn’t think it was awful television, sorry if that wasn’t clear; even when Lost isn’t great, it’s still better than most things out there.

It just felt ... I don’t know.  Kind of pointless.  I’m fine with lighter storylines and funny moments, but I felt like the van episode wasn’t really leading to anything (and really, other than the fact that we see where Ben’s father ended up, it wasn’t) and I didn’t learn anything new about any of the characters.

It felt like filler, that’s all.  Hopefully with the new shorter seasons, there will be no more filler.

Loved the review, I was getting so tired of hearing absolutely insane comments from people who are frustrated and giving up on the show. Why on earth would you do something so foolish? It’s totally unique for network television, there’s nothing else like it and it’s still got a creative and inventive story to play out. This show is a drama which has a little bit of every thing, sci-fi, action, romance, comedy and of course it’s big on mystery. People say it’s not as good as it was in the first season. That is totally not true, if you actually think about it, the quality hasn’t changed at all and we have learned so much more about the island this season than ever before, and yet the writers are still able to give interesting twists that keep the show itself a mystery. The ones who are really lost are the people that aren’t watching this show. And the ones who gave up on it shouldn’t have given up so quickly, they are missing out on a good thing for no good reason.


Comments: Page 1 of 1 pages

Advertisement

Post a Comment:







Smileys

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?



Advertisement